Plans to build a petrol station and coffee shop on land in Carlisle have been met with strong opposition from local residents, who describe the proposals as “ludicrous and stupid”.
The development, put forward by retail operator EG On The Move, would be situated next to Lidl on Warwick Road. The site lies within a flood risk zone and the buffer area of the Hadrian’s Wall World Heritage Site. Locals have raised concerns about potential flooding and increased traffic congestion in the area.
Residents have taken visible action to oppose the plans, with banners displayed at Botcherby Community Centre. Centre manager Helen Fisher described the proposals as “appalling”, noting that the junction at the end of Victoria Road is already congested following the opening of Lidl.
Local residents echoed these concerns. Leslie Mooney of Victoria Road said she found the application “ludicrous and stupid” due to the knock-on effects it would have across the city. Bethany Wood, who lives on Botcherby Avenue, added that the field plays a vital role in preventing flooding. She also noted that when Lidl was approved, development on the site was restricted because of flood risks.
Supporters of the scheme argue that the development’s proximity to a strategic highway network is essential. Planning documents submitted to Cumberland Council suggest that the petrol station and coffee shop would provide convenience facilities and transport infrastructure for staff, visitors, and residents. The project is also expected to deliver employment opportunities during construction and operation.
However, many locals remain unconvinced. Michelle Graham, a clinical educator from Victoria Road, questioned the need for another petrol station, pointing out that one exists only a few hundred yards away. Dave and Babs Israel described the plans as a “nightmare scenario” that would “bring nothing but more blight and chaos to our neighbourhood”.
The controversy highlights the tension between local development and environmental and community concerns. While the applicant emphasises economic benefits and accessibility, residents focus on safety, congestion, and the preservation of flood-prevention land. The proposals are now under review by Cumberland Council, with community feedback forming a significant part of the planning process.
